Electric Car or Plug-in Hybrid: Which One Should You Choose?

The transition to decarbonized mobility is prompting more and more drivers to ask themselves: should they choose an electric car (EV) or a plug-in hybrid (PHEV)?

An electric car is ideal for regular trips if you have easy access to a charging station or outlet at home.

A plug-in hybrid can be relevant for occasional long trips, but it remains heavier, more expensive to use, and less advantageous from an ecological standpoint.

In this article, we compare the two technologies, their costs, uses, and future prospects to help you make the right choice.

Discover and try our app

Exclusive price and features

Rated 4,5/5 by users

Download the app

What Are the Differences Between an Electric Car and a Plug-in Hybrid?

Electric Car (EV)

100% electric, the battery is powered solely by charging. Electric vehicles operate exclusively with an electric motor, without any internal combustion engine or gasoline. This simple and efficient technology is found in popular models like the Renault Zoé, Peugeot e-208, Citroën ë-C3, Toyota bZ4X, or Mercedes EQA. The electric motor directly converts the energy stored in the battery into motion, with exceptional efficiency exceeding 90%. This energy efficiency far surpasses that of traditional gasoline engines.

Range varies between 200 and 600 km depending on the vehicle. The Renault Mégane E-Tech offers up to 470 km of WLTP range, while a BMW iX3 can travel over 460 km without recharging. City cars like the Fiat 500e or Peugeot e-208 offer sufficient range for daily use, with around 350 km. High-end vehicles like the Audi e-tron GT or Mercedes EQS easily exceed 500 km of real-world range. Charging speeds are constantly improving, allowing for rapid energy recovery.

Charging can be done at home, at work, or at a station. Electric car drivers have multiple options for recharging their vehicle. At home, a simple reinforced outlet allows you to recover range overnight. Fast charging stations enable you to recover 80% of the battery in 20 to 30 minutes at high speed. The network of public charging points is continually expanding, with over 100,000 charging points available in France. Ultra-fast chargers allow for maximum-speed recharging for long trips.

Plug-in Hybrid (PHEV)

Dual powertrain: internal combustion engine + rechargeable battery. Plug-in hybrids combine a traditional gasoline or diesel engine with an electric motor powered by a limited-capacity battery. This complex architecture is found in cars like the Toyota Prius Plug-in, Mercedes Classe A 250e, BMW 330e, or Audi A3 e-tron. The system allows switching between the two propulsion modes depending on needs and available energy. Interior space can be reduced by this dual powertrain.

Electric range remains limited (30 to 80 km). Plug-in hybrid vehicles can only travel short distances in 100% electric mode. A Mercedes GLC 300e offers about 60 km, while a Citroën C5 Aircross Hybrid is limited to 55 km in pure electric mode. This limited range restricts electric use to short urban trips. Drivers must frequently switch to the gasoline engine for longer trips, consuming fuel. The choice of driving mode directly influences energy consumption.

Functions like a conventional gasoline vehicle once the battery is empty. When the battery is depleted, the plug-in hybrid vehicle uses only its gasoline engine. Fuel consumption then becomes higher than that of an equivalent gasoline vehicle, due to the additional weight of the electric system. A BMW X5 xDrive45e weighs 400 kg more than the pure gasoline version, directly impacting fuel consumption in gasoline mode and reducing available cargo space.

Comparison Table: EV vs. PHEV

Criteria	Electric Car (EV)	Plug-in Hybrid (PHEV)
Range	200 – 600 km (depending on models)	30 – 80 km (electric)
Cost per 100 km	€2 to €4 (kWh)	€6 to €9 (fuel + charging)
Maintenance	Reduced (fewer moving parts)	More complex (dual powertrain)
Incentives	Ecological bonus, conversion bonus	More limited incentives
Charging	Station, home, work	Slow charging + fuel
Weight/Space	Heavy battery, but no internal combustion engine	Heavier, reduced space

What Criteria Should You Use to Choose Based on Your Needs?

Daily Use and Type of Trips

An electric car is suitable for regular trips, such as commuting, urban, or suburban travel. Electric vehicles excel in daily use with their range, which is more than sufficient to cover the average needs of French drivers. A Renault Zoé or Peugeot e-208 can easily travel 40 to 50 km per day without ever worrying about range. Electric car drivers particularly appreciate the silent operation, absence of vibrations, and instant torque available from the start, even at low speeds. Eco driving mode further optimizes range by limiting top speed and acceleration.

A plug-in hybrid may be suitable if long trips are frequent, but its usage cost is higher. Plug-in hybrids show their limitations as soon as distances exceed their limited electric range. Consumption becomes problematic once the battery is depleted, with values often exceeding 7 liters of gasoline per 100 km for a sedan. Vehicles like the Mercedes E 300e or Audi Q5 TFSI e display high consumption in gasoline mode, negating the economic interest of the technology. Toyota offers more efficient hybrid models, but their electric range remains limited. The choice between different driving modes becomes crucial to optimize energy consumption.

Access to Charging

Having an outlet at home or easy access to a station is essential to fully enjoy an EV. Charging your electric car becomes a daily habit, as simple as plugging in your smartphone. Electric vehicles recharge while you sleep, work, or shop. A home wallbox allows you to recover full range overnight. Public stations offer fast charging solutions for occasional needs. Ultra-fast chargers allow for rapid energy recovery during long trips. Parking space with a charger becomes an important criterion for choosing a home.

Without the possibility of personal charging, a plug-in hybrid offers flexibility thanks to gasoline. But this flexibility comes at a price: using a plug-in hybrid vehicle only in gasoline mode means unnecessarily carrying hundreds of kilograms of batteries and electric motors. This usage then becomes counterproductive both ecologically and economically. CO2 emissions exceed those of an equivalent gasoline vehicle. BMW and Mercedes acknowledge that their plug-in hybrids require regular use in electric mode to be relevant. The reduced trunk space due to batteries also limits practicality.

Overall Budget (TCO)

It's a fact: EVs often cost more to buy, but their usage costs are low (energy + maintenance). The purchase price of an electric car remains higher, with, for example, €32,000 for a Renault Zoé compared to €23,000 for a gasoline Clio. However, the savings on fuel and maintenance quickly compensate for this initial extra cost. A Peugeot e-208 can save more than €1,500 per year on fuel costs compared to the gasoline version. Audi e-tron or BMW iX offer premium performance without consuming a drop of gasoline. Choosing an electric car becomes profitable from the third year for high-mileage drivers.

PHEVs benefit from fewer incentives, and their fuel costs are higher in the long run. Plug-in hybrids combine financial disadvantages: higher purchase price (often higher than electric cars), high fuel consumption, complex and costly maintenance. A BMW 330e costs more than a Tesla Model 3 to buy, while generating higher usage costs with its gasoline consumption. Government incentives now clearly favor 100% electric vehicles. Toyota, despite its hybrid expertise, is massively developing its pure electric range. Mercedes and Audi are gradually reducing their plug-in hybrid offerings in favor of all-electric vehicles.

Environment and Local Constraints

In low-emission zones (LEZ), EVs are more advantaged. Electric cars benefit from permanent unrestricted access in all French LEZs, regardless of the driving mode. Electric vehicles automatically obtain the Crit'Air 0 sticker, ensuring free circulation even during pollution peaks and at any speed. In contrast, plug-in hybrids are classified as Crit'Air 1 and could be gradually excluded from city centers. Metropolises like Paris, Lyon, or Marseille are regularly tightening their restrictions based on emissions, limiting the circulation space for thermal and hybrid vehicles.

In cold climates, the range of EVs can decrease. The batteries of electric vehicles see their capacity temporarily reduced in cold weather, with a range drop that can reach 20 to 30% in winter. The energy needed to heat the cabin increases consumption. Plug-in hybrids also suffer from this constraint, but their already limited electric range becomes almost non-existent in extreme cold. Battery pre-conditioning technologies, available on most modern electric cars like the BMW iX or Mercedes EQE, help limit this impact. Eco-driving mode helps preserve range by limiting speed and heating.

In hilly or mountainous terrain, EVs consume more but recover energy during braking. This kinetic recovery allows electric vehicles to partially recharge their battery during descents, even at high speeds. This unique feature partially compensates for the increased consumption during ascents. Plug-in hybrids have a less efficient recovery system, limited by the small capacity of their battery and the restricted space for components. Audi and Toyota are working on improving these systems, but space and weight constraints remain problematic.

How Much Does It Really Cost?

Purchase price: EVs are often more expensive, but this is offset by financial incentives. A Citroën ë-C3 starts at €23,300, a Renault Mégane E-Tech at €35,000, while a Mercedes EQA starts at €53,000. The prices of electric cars remain higher than their gasoline equivalents, but the gap is gradually narrowing. Manufacturers like Peugeot, Citroën, and Renault now offer models accessible to the general public. BMW and Audi position their electric vehicles at the same price level as their high-end gasoline versions. The choice is constantly expanding with the arrival of new vehicles.

Incentives: ecological bonus (up to €5,000) and conversion bonus. The ecological bonus can reach €5,000 for low-income households purchasing a new electric vehicle. The conversion bonus adds up to an additional €2,500 for replacing an old gasoline or diesel vehicle. These combined incentives significantly reduce the purchase price. Regions often offer additional aid for buying electric vehicles. Companies also benefit from tax advantages for acquiring electric cars, making the electric choice even more attractive. Toyota, Mercedes, and BMW also offer advantageous financing options for their electric vehicles.

Energy cost: about €2 to €4 for 100 km in an EV, compared to €6 to €9 in a PHEV. Charging an electric car at home costs about €0.15/kWh during off-peak hours, optimizing the use of nighttime energy. For an average consumption of 15 kWh/100 km, the cost per kilometer remains very low. Plug-in hybrids combine electricity and gasoline costs, resulting in a much higher final energy bill. At fast charging stations, rates remain competitive compared to fossil fuels. Public chargers offer different charging speeds depending on needs and budget. The chosen charging mode directly influences the final cost.

Maintenance: EVs are less expensive to maintain (fewer mechanical parts). The maintenance of an electric car is essentially limited to tires, brakes (which wear less thanks to regenerative braking), and cabin filters. No oil changes, no timing belt, no clutch: maintenance savings easily reach €500 per year. Plug-in hybrids require complete maintenance of the internal combustion engine plus that of the electric system, almost doubling maintenance costs. The more complex engine compartment also makes interventions more expensive. Mercedes, BMW, and Audi offer maintenance packages for their electric vehicles, but they remain much cheaper than for hybrid versions.

How to Make the Right Decision?

Quick 7-Question Checklist:

Do I travel more than 50 km per day? If so, the range of an electric car will be perfectly suited to your daily trips, regardless of the driving mode chosen.
Do I have an outlet or charging station near my home or workplace? Access to a charging solution is essential for optimal use of an electric vehicle. Public chargers are multiplying, offering more choices.
Do I regularly make long trips over 300 km at a time? Modern electric cars like the BMW iX, Audi e-tron GT, or Mercedes EQS can handle these distances without issue, even at high speeds.
Is my annual fuel budget high? The savings made with an electric car can exceed €2,000 per year for high-mileage drivers, replacing gasoline with electricity.
Am I affected by a low-emission zone (LEZ) in my city? Electric vehicles guarantee permanent unrestricted access, preserving your freedom of movement and circulation space.
Do I need a large trunk or a lightweight vehicle? The batteries of electric cars are integrated into the floor, preserving interior space. Toyota and Citroën particularly optimize living space well.
Am I ready to plan my charging or do I need immediate flexibility? Organizing recharges quickly becomes a simple habit with an electric car, regardless of your lifestyle.

What About Tomorrow? Long-Term Projections

Low-emission zones (LEZ) will strengthen the advantage of EVs (for now). These emission restrictions are gradually extending to all major French cities, reducing the circulation space for polluting vehicles. Electric cars will remain the only vehicles allowed in city centers by 2030. Plug-in hybrids, despite their reduced emissions, will face the same restrictions as gasoline vehicles. This regulatory evolution clearly favors the adoption of 100% electric vehicles. The political choice is clear: gradually phase out fossil fuels.

The residual value of EVs could increase by 2030. The used car market for electric vehicles is rapidly taking shape. Electric vehicles retain their value better than thermal or hybrid vehicles. The ban on the sale of new thermal vehicles in 2035 will support the resale prices of electric cars. Buyers are already actively seeking used electric vehicles, demonstrating confidence in this technology. BMW, Mercedes, Audi, and Toyota are investing heavily in electric vehicles, gradually abandoning plug-in hybrids. The strategic choice of manufacturers confirms the trend.

The driving comfort of EVs (silence, instant torque) is a major asset. Electric vehicle drivers almost never return to thermal after experiencing the pleasure of electric driving. The absence of engine vibrations, silent operation even at high speeds, and linear acceleration transform the driving experience. Premium brands like Mercedes, BMW, and Audi are heavily betting on electric for their high-end models. The better-optimized interior space and one-pedal driving mode are attracting more and more people. The energy recovered during braking improves overall efficiency.

Current limitations: battery weight, bulk, and variable range depending on the vehicle. Manufacturers are actively working on these improvement points. Toyota is developing solid-state batteries promising double the range for reduced weight and optimized space. Renault is heavily investing in the new generation of lithium iron phosphate batteries. The next Peugeot and Citroën electric vehicles will benefit from these technological advances. BMW and Mercedes promise vehicles with 1000 km of range by 2027. Charging speeds are also improving, with ultra-fast chargers allowing you to recover the necessary energy in less than 10 minutes. The choice of battery technology is becoming crucial for the future.

Download the Electra app on the App Store or Google Play. Locate stations, check availability, and reserve your charging point.